E.T. the Extraterrestrial (1982)

Ranking: 6 (Normalized Avg. Rating: 0.44)

Commentary from the dudes:

“It is E.T., it is required viewing. Also, what a major blunder by Hershey not allowing M&Ms, and a major win for Mars.” – Peter

“Most movies with tweenage characters annoy me, but I love this movie. The scenes in the hazmat tent will forever scare me.” – Zach